Do Children Prefer Baby-Faced Animals?

-
We know that adults prefer animals with a baby face. Research shows this applies to children too.
Photo: Hriana/Shutterstock

By Zazie Todd, PhD

It’s widely known that adults find a baby-face attractive, whether on a human baby or an animal such as a puppy or kitten. There’s a neural basis for this, which makes us want to care for babies and things that resemble them. A new study by Marta Borgi and Francesca Cirulli (2013) asks if young children show the same preference as adults for neoteny in cats and dogs.

Several research studies have found that children are attracted to animals. For example, LoBue et al (2013) found that young children have apreference for live animals over an attractive set of toys. In this study, children spent more time interacting with the animals, and also more time talking about them, than the toys.

This page contains affiliate links.

The new study asked children aged three to six about their preferences for dogs vs puppies, cats vs kittens, and dogs or cats with baby-face features vs those without. Each child sat at a laptop with the experimenter, who asked them to choose which of two photographs they preferred. The photographs showed the heads of animals as well as some showing babies or inanimate objects. 

Children showed a strong preference for infantile features in cats, preferring the kittens or the cats with baby-like features over cats without them. However, they didn’t prefer infantile features in dogs. Nonetheless they still preferred teddy bears with infantile features than those without.

The children also tended to prefer dogs to cats. When the researchers looked at pet ownership in the home, they found that children who lived with a cat were more likely to show a preference for cats than those who didn’t. It could be that children learn about cats through having regular contact with them, and are less likely to prefer them if they are unfamiliar to them. However, the number of children with a cat as a pet was quite small. Future research could investigate further the role of childhood pets in shaping children’s understanding of companion animals. 

Children preferred the photos that showed animals (dogs and cats) to those that showed either human infants or teddy bears.

Girls were more likely than boys to choose photos of dogs with infantile faces, but the same did not apply to photos of cats or teddy bears. 

Overall, these results show that even young children are able to recognize infantile features in animals and inanimate objects (teddy bears). They also show that, in general, children have a preference for animals with infantile features over those without. So a preference for neoteny seems to start early in life.

The authors acknowledge some flaws with the set of photographs, for example some had coloured backgrounds, although they were chosen as they had been used in previous research with adults. Their paper says they are already developing a more standardized set of photographs. This study also only used one measure of neoteny, called the Facial Index, and future studies could include other features (such as big eyes).

Do you prefer kittens to cats, and puppies to dogs?


Zazie Todd, PhD, is the author of Wag: The Science of Making Your Dog Happy. She is the founder of the popular blog Companion Animal Psychology, where she writes about everything from training methods to the human-canine relationship. She also writes a column for Psychology Today and has received the prestigious Captain Haggerty Award for Best Training Article in 2017. Todd lives in Maple Ridge, BC, with her husband and two cats.

Useful links:
Reference
Borgi, M., & Cirulli, F. (2013). Children's preferences for infantile features in dogs and cats Human-Animal Interaction Bulletin, 1 (2), 1-15

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. As an Etsy affiliate, I earn from qualifying Etsy purchases.

Comments

  1. anouarpac1 November 2013 at 10:07

    thanks a lot beautiful article

    ReplyDelete
  2. Unknown6 November 2013 at 18:53

    Of Course children prefer baby animals over full grown ones. They like things that are smaller than them, just like adults. Adults aren't going to find a peer "cute," same with children. They would rather have something smaller so that they are now the bigger ones. Also choosing live animals over toys is something I think almost everyone would choose. Why play with a stuffed cat when you can play with the real thing? Our minds are conditioned to think small animals are cute and nice, especially children because they know nothing better. The little albert experiment shows how to reverse this by putting a young child through a traumatic experience with a furry animal.

    ReplyDelete

Post a comment

Popular posts from this blog

Flat Collars Risk Damage to Dogs’ Necks if They Pull or You Jerk the Leash

-
Image
Don’t use leash jerks, and if your dog pulls on leash, walk them on a harness, as new research shows the potential pressure applied to a dog’s neck by the use of a flat collar.


New research published in the Veterinary Record finds that the pressure exerted on a dog’s neck by a flat collar when the dog pulls is enough to risk damage to the dog’s neck. The study, from scientists at Nottingham Trent University and the University of Nottingham, used a model to simulate the dog’s neck, and measured the forces applied when the leash was pulled. The study aimed to mimic the effects of a dog pulling consistently on a leash or the human tugging the leash (sometimes called a “leash correction”).

The results show the importance of teaching your dog to walk nicely on leash, using a harness if they do pull, and never using leash corrections.

The study tested a variety of eight different collars, including flat and padded webbing collars and leather collars, a rope slip leash, and a check chain.

Dr.…
Read more

Don't Punish Your Dog for Peeing in the House

-
Image
Why punishment is the wrong approach for house training mistakes, and how you should house train your dog or puppy instead.


By Zazie Todd, PhD

How should we house train puppies, and deal with the inevitable mistakes that puppies and adult dogs can have? Suppose your dog suddenly starts to pee in the house. You clean it up the first time but it happens again…. And then again.

Or your new puppy keeps having accidents indoors even though you take her outside often.

In this situation, some people will yell at their dog. Some might even try physical punishment like hitting the dog or an alpha roll. And we’ve all come across the advice that you should rub their nose in it.

Don’t do it.

Whether you're toilet training an adult dog or house training a puppy, here’s why that’s the wrong approach, and what you should do instead.

Punishment can make things worse First of all, let’s think about it from the dog’s perspective.

Suppose they pee in the house and you yell at them. What do they learn…
Read more

Positive Reinforcement is More Effective at Training Dogs than an Electronic Collar, Study Shows

-
Image
New research got professional dog trainers to train dogs who had issues with off-leash disobedience. Positive reinforcement worked better than an electronic collar, without the risks. 

By Zazie Todd, PhD
We’ve known for a while that training dogs with aversive methods, including electronic collars, has risks for animal welfare. Positive reinforcement training is effective and does not have those risks. New research from the University of Lincoln, published today in Frontiers in Veterinary Science, finds that in a typical situation where proponents of electronic collars often recommend them, positive reinforcement training by trainers who specialize in reward-based training works better than training with or without a shock collar by trainers who would normally use a shock collar. 
The scientists say, “These findings refute the suggestion that training with an E-collar is either more efficient or results in less disobedience, even in the hands of experienced trainers. In many ways, trainin…
Read more